Last Update 4/17/23

With the Battle Cruisers by Filton Young, Naval Press, 1926 

This is the memoir of a naval officer who served during World War I. It provides a very good picture of what it was like to live at sea during that period, and Young was a perceptive man able to transfer his experiences to the written word. He did not, however, have a particularly exciting time and was not present for most of the important battles - both sides protected their navies assiduously, thus rendering them largely irrrelevant, so this is not as good at providing the historical background. This is a reprint edition. 4/17/23

Kursk by Rupert Matthews, Arcturus, 2016 zz472 

This is an account of the largest tank battle in history. Germany was hoping to regain the initiative after the catastrophe at Stalingrad. They had superior equipment and believed that the Russians defending Kursk had only a relatively small numerical advantage that could be easily overcome. Actually their intelligence was faulty and they were outnumbered better than two to one, including tanks and artillery. The Russians also had the benefit of British intelligence intercepts of German messages, so they had a pretty good idea what was going to happen, where, and when. The Germans lost, and that meant the invasion of Russia was doomed.  This is a fairly good account but it needed more and better maps. 4/1/23

Nnedi Okorafor by Sandra J. Lindow, McFarland, 2022, $39.95, ISBN 978-1-4766-8332-4

This is obviously an in depth look at the work of one of the more promising new writers of the last decade - she has only been active since 2015. Okorafor is one of those rare writers whose work is frequently surprising because she tries so many different things, an attribute which alas does not often result in a strong following among readers who generally want more of the same. She seems to be proving to be an exception. I have only read about half of the stories mentioned in this book, so I was occasionally a bit at a loss about the discussions, although generally the author provides enough context to smooth this over. It includes a discussion of some graphic stories and some nonfiction. Okorafor sometimes blurs the distinction between science fiction and fantasy - not one of my favorite devices - but many people are not similar bothered. This is aimed at a scholarly audience, although her more serious fans should also find it of interest. 3/31/23

Gallipoli 1915 by Joseph Murray, New English Library, 1965 

This is not strictly speaking a history. The author was one of the soldiers sent in an attempt to knock Turkey out of the first world war, or at least to regain access to the Black Sea. While he was there, he made copious notes about his experiences, which he periodically mailed home. This is an edited collection of his thoughts, observations, experiences, and feelings about the war. It makes the campaign which was probably doomed from the outset seem like a more human endeavor, and more tragic because of that. 3/23/23

Delivered from Evil by Robert Leckie, Harper, 1987

This is a one volume, thousand page history of World War II. It begins with the Treaty of Versailles, provides biographies of the major figures, then discusses and describes the various political and military developments through the surrender of Japan. William Shirer's Rise and Fall of the Third Reich is still the best account of the European war but this also covers the conflict in the Pacific. The prose is smooth and entertaining. The organization of the material is excellent. The depth of detail in a single book is surprising. My only complaint is that it really needed more maps to understand some of the battles. Considering how much I had already read about World War II, it is surprising how fresh and revelatory it felt to read it - and I did so over the course of more than two weeks. 2/3/23

The Life of Crime by Martin Edwards, Collins, 2022

This is a very large, ambitious attempt to chart the history of the crime story, everything from Edgar Allan Poe to Sara Paretsky, Eric Ambler to Agatha Christie to Raymond Chandler. There is also coverage of mysteries from France, Scandinavia, Japan, and other countries and some mention of radio mysteries and movies. The breadth of the topic is so large that the entries are necessarily somewhat superficial. Some prolific and well known writers are not even mentioned - J. Jefferson Farjeon, Josephine Bell, Christopher Bush, etc. - and most others receive only a paragraph or a footnote. The individual chapters are arranged only vaguely chronologically. They focus on individual subsets like women in jeopardy, locked rooms, tough detectives, psychological thrillers, etc. Scattered through the text are some anecdotes - I did not know that Mary Roberts Rinehart survived a murder attempt by her chef, for example. If nothing else, the book demonstrates that crime fiction is just as diverse as other genres, mores so than some. This is a reference book that will join a dozen others as permanent resident of the shelf beside my desk. 1/7/23

A Literary Octavia E. Butler Companion by Mary Ellen Snodgrass, McFarland, 2022, $49.95, ISBN 978-1476688756c

Octavia Butler's reputation has grown steadily despite the relatively small body of work she produced during her lifetime. This is meant to be a supplement designed either to help a reader understand the possibly hidden complexity of the author's work, but also as a guide for group discussions, formal classes, and other similar situations. There is a fairly substantial biography and chronicle of Butler's writing career, followed by the main section which discusses both her fiction and her non-fiction. The prose is rather academic at times, but the observations seem to be accurate and informative. I'm not sure that I agree that Butler was as prophetic as is sometimes suggested, but science fiction writers have never been particularly great at prophesy and that's really not what they are about anyway. The price is a bit stiff so you might want to talk your library into ordering a copy. 1/3/23

   MORE REVIEWS